Wednesday, May 29, 2013

Spring Trip 2013, Day 15: Oradour-sur-Glane

I hadn’t planned on posting again until tomorrow evening, but I had an experience during my journey to the Loire Valley today that I want to share while it is still fresh in my memory. I had a long drive ahead of me this morning, nearly five hours total from the Dordogne to the Loire, and it just so happened that I had read about and also had recommended to me a great sightseeing opportunity along the way, so I decided to use that opportunity to break up the long drive. That opportunity was at Oradour-sur-Glane, a village near Limoges in west-central France. Oradour is well-known in France for being the site of a terrible massacre of more than 600 civilians by Nazi troops during World War II. The village was left exactly as it was after the massacre and has been preserved in exactly the same condition ever since, providing visitors the opportunity to catch a glimpse of the reality of that tragic event. It is similar to the concentration camps in Germany which I have visited and written about on this blog before in that at Oradour, the French people invite the world to come see what happened there, so that they will never forget. It is an incredibly powerful and moving site to behold, and I recommend anyone visiting either the Loire or the Dordogne, especially if going between the two, to stop by and see it for themselves.

The site is appropriately spartan, taking care not to distract visitors from the sobering display they are there to witness. When you first arrive you do not see the village at all, but rather just the tastefully composed entrance to the site’s museum. The museum sets the stage for you, telling the story both in words and images of how Adolf Hitler and the Nazi party came to power in Germany, how they invaded France and occupied the northern half while allowing a sympathetic government (known as the Vichy government or Vichy France) to administer the southern half, and how events progressed leading up to the massacre at Oradour. By 1944, when the massacre took place, Germany had become stretched thin and was losing control of the vast territory, from France to Russia, that it had conquered using its blitzkrieg strategy early in the war. As Nazi repression subsequently weakened in Vichy France, resistance elements arose and grew increasingly vocal, and the Vichy government tolerated them. The Nazis took notice, however, and as control began to slip away they sought to reaffirm it. The Nazis wanted to make an example, and they chose Oradour as the place to do it. Internal communication which is documented at the museum shows that the Nazis planned a brutal crackdown, and that they even made the Vichy government aware of their plans. While it is not clear how much the Vichy government knew of what the Nazis planned, it is clear that they stood by and did nothing to prevent it. On June 10, 1944, a detachment of the Nazi Waffen SS (composed in part of forced French conscripts) surrounded Oradour and then moved their way into the village, forcing anyone they encountered to gather in the center of the village. They then confined all of the women and children to the village church and separated the men into several groups, which they took away to different parts of the village. On a pre-arranged signal the Nazis opened fire on the groups of men, killing them. They then set fire to the church, killing the women and children too. Finally the Nazis set fire to the village, completely destroying it. All told, 642 villagers were murdered, while just a handful of fortunate escapees survived.

After exiting the museum, visitors are directed toward the village itself. You emerge from the museum and find a set of stairs rising before you with a gate at the top and a stone plaque that says simply “Remember”. Upon reaching the top of the stairs you find yourself at the edge of the ruined village. It looks very much like any other French village, except every single building is a ruin. The streets look like regular French streets, the power line poles are still standing, and there are even the remains of reclining patient’s chairs in the village dentist’s office and the rusted shell of a car on the street. But all of the buildings are open to the sky, every bit of wood they ever possessed consumed by Nazi fire. There are plaques on many of the buildings indicating what they were; the post office, the school, the barber shop, the café, etc. Here and there you see plaques that tell you where each of the groups of men was murdered. Visitors are free to walk anywhere, including the very spots where the victims were killed. At the far end of the village from where visitors enter is the church, where the most heinous act – the murder of the women and children – was committed. There, too, visitors can walk inside and see what remains of the last thing on earth the victims ever saw. Finally, the village cemetery lies just outside of the ruined village, where the victims who could be identified are buried. There is also a plaque with the names of the children who were murdered there. There is a sign at the entrance to the village that says “Silence,” but for the most part it probably isn’t necessary; words escape you when you walk through the village and see what remains, imagining what was there before the massacre and what it looked like in the midst. I saw probably 20-30 other visitors in the village, and heard not a world spoken among them.

Oradour-sur-Glane
Like when I visited the Dachau concentration camp last December, I was close to tears as I took in what I was seeing. I imagined the fear, the pain, the anguish of the victims, and I felt overwhelmed with shock and grief, even as an outsider looking in separated by decades from the actual event. My recurring thought was that the entire world owes those victims a debt that it can never repay. The world could have prevented that unspeakable tragedy, but it failed to. Our own country could have intervened sooner, but we declined to. I understand that those actions and decisions are far more complicated than that. But when you see and feel what places like Oradour have to show the world and inspire within us, those decisions don’t seem so complicated after all. Like I said about Picasso’s Guernica, anyone who wants to go to war or persecute any other person or group should be required to visit a place like Oradour first, for at Oradour we see the true price of war, the true and ultimate consequence of regarding any person or group of people as less than or substantively different from ourselves. Although speaking of true and ultimate consequences, perhaps, depending on what you believe, justice was done in the end. It is not mine or anyone else’s place to judge, but for my part, I believe it was.

No comments:

Post a Comment